A SHARP CRITIQUE OF OUR LAND REFORM PROGRAM
A SHARP CRITIQUE OF OUR LAND REFORM PROGRAM Recently, I came across a powerful essay written by Ms. Sharon Gick entitled "The Land Was Never Theirs to Give." Whether one agrees with all of her conclusions or not, her work deserves serious attention because it raises difficult questions about the real outcomes of agrarian reform in the Philippines. According to Ms. Gick, the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) did not fully liberate farmers from poverty. Instead, she argues that many beneficiaries received land titles accompanied by long-term debt obligations, while lacking access to credit, equipment, infrastructure, and support services needed to make their farms productive. Her most provocative observation is that many agrarian reform beneficiaries were given ownership documents but could not easily use these titles as collateral for financing. As a result, farmers often found themselves trapped between the need for capital and the inability to obtain it. Whether ...